General Relativity -Part 1

General theory of relativity was published in 1915, by the famous Einstein. And it is primarily about gravity. The main postulate of the theory (it was only a mathematically derived theory when it was published, the experimental evidence was found later after it was published) is that matter tells space time how to curve. And that curvature tells matter how to move. 

There were 2 main ideas that Einstein focused on and explored, that the theory explains. I'll talk about the first main idea here. And we'll cover the second one in the next blog. 

What Einstein first honed in on and got curious about was the matter as depicted in Newton's laws. The story of matter and motion began much earlier. Newton's laws published in 1687 described the motion of objects. Inertial mass is a measure of an object's resistance to changing its state of motion (its resistance to acceleration) when a force is applied. It is quantified using Newton's second law of motion via the formula:

F = mi . a 

(Force equals mass times acceleration), implying an object with a larger inertial mass (mi) requires a much greater force to achieve the same acceleration as an object with a smaller inertial mass. This is indeed intuitive. 

Newton’s third law, law of universal gravitation says that every two masses attract one another. The force increases with the two objects’ gravitational masses and decreases with the square of the distance between their centers.

F = G. Mg1 . Mg2 / r^2

Here G is a constant, r is distance between the objects. Mg1 and Mg2 are gravitational masses of 2 objects where gravitational mass is the property that determines both how strongly an object creates gravity and how strongly it responds to another object’s gravity. For an object close to earth, this formula is shown as:
F = G . Me . Mg /r^2
Where Me is the mass of earth, r is distance to the center of the earth. The constants G.Me/r^2 are represented as a constant g which is the gravitational field of earth. 

Close to earth, the above newton's second law becomes 

F = g . Mg
Where Mg is the gravitational mass of the object. 

Now, during a free fall, the object experiences a force and acceleration, given by Newton's 2nd law 
F = Mi . a 
But also, since this is a free fall, this force is nothing but the gravitational force, which can also be represented by Newton's 3rd law as
F = Mg . g  
Since on free fall no external force is applied on the object other than gravitational, these 2 equations are equal. 
Mi . a = Mg . g
a = (Mg/Mi) . g

Multiple experiments with multiple types of objects and materials have showed (Mg/Mi) to be 1 for all objects. Meaning, an object's inertial mass (the measure of an object's resistance to changing its state of motion) is exactly the same as it's gravitational mass (the measure of an object's resistance to gravity). 

This is what is termed the equivalence principle. Now this was not a new finding by Einstein. Newton already knew about it and saw this equivalence as an accident. Even before Newton, Galileo had published his Galileo's law of free fall in 1638 which stated that in a vacuum, all bodies fall with the same constant acceleration regardless of their mass, size, or weight. If objects displayed different acceleration during free fall, then their (Mg/Mi) ratio would be different as well. But experimentally they were found to be exactly equal to 1. Quite famously these were demonstrations Galileo did using the leaning tower of Pisa, and dropping objects of different sizes. (We now know, the MICROSCOPE satellite compared the free fall of two test masses of different composition using precision accelerometers. And it found Mg = Mi with 10^15 precision.)

So while these observations were written into a law over 250 years before Einstein, when he noticed it, he made the leap of the next implication.. if the gravitational mass is same as the inertial mass for all objects, that implies gravity is somehow inexplicably related to acceleration. It is in this leap that Einstein's genius is seen. And he did multiple thought experiments that make this link even more clear, almost self- evident. But let this sink in for a minute. He took a finding that was observed by his predecessors more than 250 years ago, thought to be an accident, something observed but not thought to be consequential enough.. he looked at that and took the next leap of intuition and interpretation. And that's what led to the most consequential theory in the history of physics or even mankind. 

When I read about Einstein, it's apparent to me he was a physicist bordering on mathematician (as all physicists are!). But he was driven from some place else, he was not just working on one equation after the other seeing where the equations take him. He was driven by some broader sense of meaning or symmetry or intuition of what or how things fit together. What is the nature of this existence! And then he used the equations to prove his intuitions. At the crux of it, Einstein's insights that led to relativity was about his systems thinking mindset. And it is a source of great inspiration for us all. As we continue to see in his work, he relied prolifically on works from other mathematicians and scientists. What he brought was the ability to tie unrelated concepts together. Where Newton and Galileo, both geniuses themselves, saw the same things, Einstein in this theory took it several thoughts further. As a technologist and having worked on complex distributed systems, detailed implementation may seem to come at the cost of taking a wider lens at the technology landscape and developing an intuitive understanding of how things fit together. And yet it is this marriage of the ability to understand the details together with the wider sense of understanding the nature of a system that is the most useful. I've seen some of the Systems Analysts or Business Analysts that have that almost intuition as to where an obscure fault is coming from. 

Einstein's "happiest thought" as it is now called, came from this thought experiment.. say you stand on a weighing machine on the ground, and the machine reads a certain number. Now imagine you're on a tall ladder and you tape the weighing machine to your feet. If you fall off the ladder, while you're falling, the machine will read your weight as 0. Why is that? Because you are no longer pushing on the scale. Both the scale and you are being accelerated towards the earth at the same rate, and while that is happening, it seems to negate the effect that you were pushing on the scale. If you release a ball or untape the scale, they will fall freely next to you, appearing to be floating. In that local frame of reference of a free falling body, gravity gets canceled out because of the objects being in acceleration of a free fall. Similarly in a free falling elevator, a released ball floats side by side, and in that small, local frame of reference the objects behave as if gravity is absent. So in the presence of acceleration, in the local frame of reference, gravity seems to disappear. 

The opposite works too. On a spaceship in space with no gravity, if you accelerate the ship upwards, you'll feel the floor pushing up on the feet and the weight scale will register a non zero reading - feeling very much like the effect of gravity. A released ball in this case will fall towards the floor of the space ship.

 So in the absence of gravity, acceleration simulates gravity. What this implied is that gravity is closely related to acceleration. This is the equivalence principle, that acceleration and gravity are equivalent; and one of the 2 big ideas Einstein built his theory of General Relativity on. For the next big idea, stay tuned for next time..


Comments

Popular Posts